Shop All Plush, Balls, & Mice Toys

Available Filters

Category

Brand

Price

Animal/Pet Type

47 products
Filters
Sort

Sort

image of Carrot Catnip Cat Toy

Main St. Pet

Carrot Catnip Cat Toy

Sku: 10055189

$5.09

$5.99

Save $0.90

Add To Cart
image of Eggplants Catnip Cat Toys, 2 pk

Main St. Pet

Eggplants Catnip Cat Toys, 2 pk

Sku: 10055238

$4.75

$5.59

Save $0.84

Add To Cart
image of Plush Round Mouse Crinkle Cat Toy

Main St. Pet

Plush Round Mouse Crinkle Cat Toy

Sku: 10055185

$4.24

$4.99

Save $0.75

Add To Cart
image of Feathered Balls Catnip Cat Toys, 2 pk

Main St. Pet

Feathered Balls Catnip Cat Toys, 2 pk

Sku: 10055224

$6.79

$7.99

Save $1.20

Add To Cart
image of Yarn Ball Cat Toy

Main St. Pet

Yarn Ball Cat Toy

Sku: 10055123

$5.09

$5.99

Save $0.90

Add To Cart
image of Plush Mouse Catnip Cat Toy

Main St. Pet

Plush Mouse Catnip Cat Toy

Sku: 10055176

$4.24

$4.99

Save $0.75

Add To Cart
image of Ball & Mice Variety Pack Cat Toys, 7 pc

Main St. Pet

Ball & Mice Variety Pack Cat Toys, 7 pc

Sku: 10055145

$5.94

$6.99

Save $1.05

Add To Cart
image of Cat Toy- Lattice Balls with Bell, 4 pk

Ethical Pet Products

Cat Toy- Lattice Balls with Bell, 4 pk

Sku: 22590172

$4.50

$5.29

Save $0.79

Add To Cart
image of Lamb Chop Dog Toy, 10.5-Inch

Multipet

Lamb Chop Dog Toy, 10.5-Inch

Sku: 23490738

$9.34

$10.99

Save $1.65

Add To Cart
image of Lamb Chop Cat Toy, 4-Inch

Multipet

Lamb Chop Cat Toy, 4-Inch

Sku: 23491036

$5.94

$6.99

Save $1.05

Add To Cart
image of Beaver Toy, X-Large

Critter Skinz

Beaver Toy, X-Large

Sku: 21590970

$16.14

$18.99

Save $2.85

Add To Cart
image of Textured Latext Stuffed Cow

Wrangler

Textured Latext Stuffed Cow

Sku: 33210005

$13.59

$15.99

Save $2.40

Add To Cart
image of Loofa Cat Kicker With Catnip, 10-Inch

Multipet

Loofa Cat Kicker With Catnip, 10-Inch

Sku: 23491038

$6.79

$7.99

Save $1.20

Add To Cart
image of Ethical Pet Products 14-in Skinneeez Extreme Stuffer Pig

Skinneeez

Ethical Pet Products 14-in Skinneeez Extreme Stuffer Pig

Sku: 22590110

$11.04

$12.99

Save $1.95

Add To Cart
image of Feather Balls with Bells Cat Toys, 2 pk

Main St. Pet

Feather Balls with Bells Cat Toys, 2 pk

$5.09

$5.99

Save $0.90

Add To Cart
image of Crinkle Ball Catnip Cat Toy

Main St. Pet

Crinkle Ball Catnip Cat Toy

Sku: 10055175

$4.24

$4.99

Save $0.75

Add To Cart
image of Smoked Fish Catnip Cat Toy

Main St. Pet

Smoked Fish Catnip Cat Toy

$9.34

$10.99

Save $1.65

Add To Cart
image of Mice Catnip Cat Toys, 3 pk

Main St. Pet

Mice Catnip Cat Toys, 3 pk

Sku: 10055222

$2.88

$3.39

Save $0.51

Add To Cart
image of Banana Crinkle Catnip Cat Toy

Main St. Pet

Banana Crinkle Catnip Cat Toy

Sku: 10055219

$5.94

$6.99

Save $1.05

Add To Cart
image of Pea Pods Catnip Cat Toys, 2 pk

Main St. Pet

Pea Pods Catnip Cat Toys, 2 pk

Sku: 10055240

$4.75

$5.59

Save $0.84

Add To Cart
image of Toy & Ball Variety Pack Cat Toys, 4 pc

Main St. Pet

Toy & Ball Variety Pack Cat Toys, 4 pc

Sku: 10055181

$3.82

$4.49

Save $0.67

Add To Cart