Shop All Nostalgic and Novelty Candy

Available Filters

Category

Brand

Price

89 products
Filters
Sort

Sort

image of Sugar Daddy Milk Caramel Pop, 1.7 oz

Tootsie Roll

Sugar Daddy Milk Caramel Pop, 1.7 oz

Sku: 50905634

$2.99

Add To Cart
image of Charleston Chew Vanilla Bar, 1.88 oz

Tootsie Roll

Charleston Chew Vanilla Bar, 1.88 oz

Sku: 50901667

$2.49

Add To Cart
image of 16 ct Original Mix Fruit Chewy Candy

Now & Later

16 ct Original Mix Fruit Chewy Candy

Sku: 50900076

$2.99

Add To Cart
image of King Size Original Salted Nut Roll Bar, 3.25 oz

Pearsons

King Size Original Salted Nut Roll Bar, 3.25 oz

Sku: 11330003

$2.69

Add To Cart
image of Tongue Torcher Candy, 7.5 oz

Atwoods

Tongue Torcher Candy, 7.5 oz

Sku: 50902173

$4.29

Add To Cart
image of Peanut Caramel Bar, 1.85 oz

Payday

Peanut Caramel Bar, 1.85 oz

Sku: 50909656

$2.49

Add To Cart
image of Fizz Powder Candy Strings (Flavor May Vary)

Zots

Fizz Powder Candy Strings (Flavor May Vary)

Sku: 50901706

$0.69

Add To Cart
image of Original Salted Nut Roll, 1.6 oz

Pearsons

Original Salted Nut Roll, 1.6 oz

Sku: 11330002

$1.49

Add To Cart
image of Peppermint Salt Water Taffy, 8.5 oz

Atwoods

Peppermint Salt Water Taffy, 8.5 oz

Sku: 50902166

$4.29

Add To Cart
image of Watermelon Licorice, 9.5 oz

Atwoods

Watermelon Licorice, 9.5 oz

Sku: 50902164

$4.29

Add To Cart
image of Cinnamon Licorice, 9.5 oz

Atwoods

Cinnamon Licorice, 9.5 oz

Sku: 50902162

$4.29

Add To Cart
image of XL Classic Red Licorice, 22 oz

Atwoods

XL Classic Red Licorice, 22 oz

Sku: 50900005

$7.99

Add To Cart
image of Nostalgic Milk Chocolate Almond Bar, 3.5 oz

Hershey's

Nostalgic Milk Chocolate Almond Bar, 3.5 oz

Sku: 50900901

$3.49

Add To Cart
image of Nostalgic Milk Chocolate Bar, 3.5 oz

Hershey's

Nostalgic Milk Chocolate Bar, 3.5 oz

Sku: 50902077

$3.49

Add To Cart
image of King Size Whatchamacallit Candy Bar, 2.6 oz

Hershey's

King Size Whatchamacallit Candy Bar, 2.6 oz

Sku: 50910040

$3.69

Add To Cart
image of Original Chocolatey Candies, 1.75 oz

Sixlets

Original Chocolatey Candies, 1.75 oz

Sku: 50902051

$2.49

Add To Cart
image of Razzles Original Candy/Gum, 1.4 oz

Tootsie Roll

Razzles Original Candy/Gum, 1.4 oz

Sku: 50901023

$2.99

Add To Cart
image of 7 ct Peppermint Hard Candy Roll

Reeds

7 ct Peppermint Hard Candy Roll

Sku: 50900204

$1.99

Add To Cart
image of Original Caramel Hard Candies, 5.5 oz

Werther's

Original Caramel Hard Candies, 5.5 oz

Sku: 50900056

$4.49

Add To Cart
image of Pop Candy (Flavor May Vary)

Baby Bottle

Pop Candy (Flavor May Vary)

Sku: 50900561

$3.29

Add To Cart
image of 6 oz Old Fashioned Hard Candies, Lemon

Claeys Candy

6 oz Old Fashioned Hard Candies, Lemon

Sku: 70900033

$2.29

Add To Cart
image of 7 ct Cinnamon Hard Candy Roll

Reeds

7 ct Cinnamon Hard Candy Roll

Sku: 50900205

$1.99

Add To Cart
image of Ring Pop (Flavor May Vary)

Fruit Fest

Ring Pop (Flavor May Vary)

Sku: 50900008

$1.69

Add To Cart
image of Watermelon Popping Candy

Pop Rocks

Watermelon Popping Candy

Sku: 50908178

$1.49

Add To Cart