Shop All Nostalgic and Novelty Candy

Filters

Available Filters

Brand

Price

79 products
image of 12 Flavor Gummi Bears, 10 oz

Atwoods

12 Flavor Gummi Bears, 10 oz

Sku: 50900261

$4.29

Add To Cart
image of Cinnamon Salt Water Taffy, 19 oz

Atwoods

Cinnamon Salt Water Taffy, 19 oz

Sku: 50900090

$7.99

Add To Cart
image of 2.5 oz Pecan Log Candy Bar

Crown Homestyle Candies

2.5 oz Pecan Log Candy Bar

Sku: 50900001

$3.29

Add To Cart
image of Chocolate Caramel Coconut Haystack, 9.5 oz

Atwoods

Chocolate Caramel Coconut Haystack, 9.5 oz

Sku: 50902180

$4.29

Add To Cart
image of 1.7 oz Sugar Daddy Milk Caramel Pop

Tootsie Roll

1.7 oz Sugar Daddy Milk Caramel Pop

Sku: 50905634

$2.99

Add To Cart
image of 1.88 oz Charleston Chew Vanilla Bar

Tootsie Roll

1.88 oz Charleston Chew Vanilla Bar

Sku: 50901667

$2.49

Add To Cart
image of 3.25 oz King Size Original Salted Nut Roll Bar

Pearsons

3.25 oz King Size Original Salted Nut Roll Bar

Sku: 11330003

$2.69

Black Friday Prices Now: 2/$3
Add To Cart
image of Peppermint Salt Water Taffy, 8.5 oz

Atwoods

Peppermint Salt Water Taffy, 8.5 oz

Sku: 50902166

$4.29

Add To Cart
image of XL Classic Red Licorice, 22 oz

Atwoods

XL Classic Red Licorice, 22 oz

Sku: 50900005

$7.99

Add To Cart
image of Sugar Free Peanut Butter Bars, 7 oz

Atwoods

Sugar Free Peanut Butter Bars, 7 oz

Sku: 50909782

$5.99

Add To Cart
image of 1 oz Fluffy Stuff Cotton Candy

Charms

1 oz Fluffy Stuff Cotton Candy

Sku: 50901395

$2.99

Add To Cart
image of 2.25 oz Peanut Rounder

Anderson

2.25 oz Peanut Rounder

Sku: 12780020

$1.19

Add To Cart
image of 3.4 oz King Size Peanut Caramel Bar

Payday

3.4 oz King Size Peanut Caramel Bar

Sku: 50900115

$3.69

Add To Cart
image of Supreme Coconut Bar

Atwoods

Supreme Coconut Bar

Sku: 50900065

$2.49

Add To Cart
image of 1.88 oz Charleston Chew Chocolaty Bar

Tootsie Roll

1.88 oz Charleston Chew Chocolaty Bar

Sku: 50901670

$2.99

Add To Cart
image of 1.7 oz Hazardously Sour Candy Drum (Flavor May Vary)

Toxic Waste

1.7 oz Hazardously Sour Candy Drum (Flavor May Vary)

Sku: 50900042

$2.49

Add To Cart
image of 1.6 oz Original Salted Nut Roll

Pearsons

1.6 oz Original Salted Nut Roll

Sku: 11330002

$1.49

Add To Cart
image of 2.5 oz Almond Log Candy Bar

Crown Homestyle Candies

2.5 oz Almond Log Candy Bar

Sku: 50900262

$2.99

Add To Cart
image of 2 oz Sifer's Candy Cups

Valomilk

2 oz Sifer's Candy Cups

Sku: 50907771

$3.49

Add To Cart
image of 5.5 oz Sugar Free Original Caramel Hard Candies

Werther's

5.5 oz Sugar Free Original Caramel Hard Candies

Sku: 50900058

$4.49

Add To Cart
image of 20 oz Sour Cherry Candy

Atwoods

20 oz Sour Cherry Candy

Sku: 29419052

$7.49

Add To Cart