Shop All Nostalgic and Novelty Candy

Filters

Available Filters

Brand

Price

86 products
image of Marshmallow Charms

Atwoods

Marshmallow Charms

Sku: 50910116

$2.50

Show Details
image of Bit-O-Honey, 15 oz

Atwoods

Bit-O-Honey, 15 oz

Sku: 50909912

$7.99

Show Details
image of Vanilla Coconut Dips - 9.5 oz

Atwoods

Vanilla Coconut Dips - 9.5 oz

Sku: 50902181

$4.29

Show Details
image of Pecan Log

Crown Homestyle Candies

Pecan Log

Sku: 50900001

$2.69

Show Details
image of Tootsie Roll Charleston Chew Nougat Bar

Charleston Chew

Tootsie Roll Charleston Chew Nougat Bar

Sku: 50901667

$1.99

Show Details
image of Mixed Coconut Dips, 9.5 oz

Atwoods

Mixed Coconut Dips, 9.5 oz

Sku: 50902180

$4.29

Show Details
image of Maple Toffee Nut Candy, 13.5 oz

Atwoods

Maple Toffee Nut Candy, 13.5 oz

Sku: 50909119

$3.29

Show Details
image of Sugar Daddy Milk Caramel LolliPop

Charms

Sugar Daddy Milk Caramel LolliPop

Sku: 50905634

$2.39

Show Details
image of Nut Roll Bar

Pearsons

Nut Roll Bar

Sku: 11330003

$2.29

Show Details
image of Peanut Butter Bars, 7.5 oz

Atwoods

Peanut Butter Bars, 7.5 oz

Sku: 50902171

$4.29

Show Details
image of Tootsie Roll Midgees, 18 oz

Atwoods

Tootsie Roll Midgees, 18 oz

Sku: 50909908

$7.99

Show Details
image of Hot Tamale, 10 oz

Atwoods

Hot Tamale, 10 oz

Sku: 50902192

$3.99

Show Details
image of Fluffy Stuff Cotton Candy

Charms

Fluffy Stuff Cotton Candy

Sku: 50901395

$2.39

Show Details
image of Peanut Butter Bar, 7.5 oz

Atkinson

Peanut Butter Bar, 7.5 oz

Sku: 50909782

$5.99

Show Details
image of Peanut Rounder

Anderson

Peanut Rounder

Sku: 12780020

$0.89

Show Details
image of King Size Peanut Caramel Bar

Payday

King Size Peanut Caramel Bar

Sku: 50900115

$3.29

Show Details
image of Tootsie Roll Charleston Chew Chocolate Nougat Bar

Charleston Chew

Tootsie Roll Charleston Chew Chocolate Nougat Bar

Sku: 50901670

$2.39

Show Details
image of Sour Candy Drum, Flavor May Vary

Toxic Waste

Sour Candy Drum, Flavor May Vary

Sku: 50900042

$1.79

Show Details
image of Cinnamon Juju Bears, 28 oz

Atwoods

Cinnamon Juju Bears, 28 oz

Sku: 50909909

$7.99

Show Details
image of Almond Log

Crown Homestyle Candies

Almond Log

Sku: 50900262

$2.29

Show Details
image of Goetze Mini Cow Tales Chewy Caramel Candy

Cow Tales

Goetze Mini Cow Tales Chewy Caramel Candy

Sku: 50905744

$1.69

Show Details